In February 2023, I wrote an article asking whether I could stop contributing to my children’s 529s and get them a ChatGPT account instead.
Partly joking. Partly hoping someone would say yes.
I wondered whether technology could make education more accessible and leave parents with more money for experiences with their children today.
Nearly four years later, I’ve been looking at elementary schools and asking a version of the same question.
I looked at Waldorf. I looked at Alpha. Both appealed to my desire for an education that gives children room to develop beyond the conventional school day. Their approaches could hardly have looked more different.
At Waldorf, I was dazzled by the library. Standing among the books, digging through decades of lost memory, I asked, “Is this the Dewey decimal system?” It was.
At Alpha, I didn’t see a book.
Yet the more I connected the dots, the more I saw how much they had in common underneath it all. Both were offering a different path toward the same things I wanted for my children: room to follow their interests, develop independence, and learn through experiences beyond traditional academics.
One looked to methods that predated my own education. The other looked to technology that will reshape my, and their, future. I could see the appeal of both.
And with that, I decided the middle ground of public education was best suited to our current needs.
Then came this year’s MAP results.
The child reflected in those scores didn’t look like the child I knew, or the one reflected in years of previous assessments. I wanted to understand what had happened. Had something been missed? Was the classroom too distracting? Could my child get the attention she needed in a room that size?
Back to the drawing board. Back to private-school websites. Back to wondering what we could afford and what, exactly, we would be buying.
Alpha interested me because of its promise of individualized learning and more time for enrichment. But tuition around $40,000 a year in Austin, and as much as $75,000 elsewhere, demands some serious consideration.
An October 23 New York Times investigation added to my questions. Reviewing Alpha’s internal data, the newspaper reported that “only 42 percent progressed twice as fast in both math and reading.”
When I hear “twice as fast,” I imagine two years of learning in one. What’s actually being measured is twice the projected growth on MAP, the same standardized assessment my children take. That could be meaningful. But before I spend $40,000 a year, I want to understand the difference.
None of this means the children weren’t learning. The Times reported high achievement overall, and some parents described children who were happy and thriving. Others reported children who were…not. Accelerated learning is central to Alpha’s promise. As a prospective parent, I want to understand the gap between that promise and the experience of individual children.
But as a millennial caught up in the mental health swirl of the last decade, every time I open an app or a newspaper, I’m being asked to be present and slow down.
So is acceleration a good thing? Are we making them accelerate past the years when they’re supposed to enjoy finding their own speed? To actually relish moving through the world before the clock starts ticking.
I feel like our current generational ailment is the speed at which we think we must perform. We’re trying to unlearn it, manage our anxiety, and figure out how to be present. And yet here we are, considering paying a premium to get our children moving faster.
Are we forcing our own chronic, hazardous speed onto the next generation? Creating a multigenerational ailment out of our own ailment?
My kids don’t have performance anxiety, nor do I want them to have it at ages five and seven. I want them to have time to find their own speed before they feel they have to keep up with ours.
I also found myself wondering whether I could assemble another approach. A $20-a-month ChatGPT subscription to help me plan learning. An experienced educator to review it, teach, and assess progress. Small groups, music, theatre, sport, and time out in the world.
That wouldn’t recreate Alpha’s proprietary platform. It would be its own experiment, with its own costs, logistical problems, and demands on my time. Still, it seemed worth asking.
And then I came back to something less technological.
There will be distractions wherever my children go. Learning involves gradually developing the ability to work through some of them. Changing schools might solve a particular problem, but it won’t produce an environment free of frustration, noise, or other people’s needs.
I want my children supported as they develop those skills. I also want them to have room to be five and seven.
They are artists, musicians, and creators. I see abilities in them that a reading or math score cannot describe. I want the way we assess them to reflect those abilities, too, because they are part of their education and their potential.
Imagine what we all could have become if our creativity had been evaluated as rigorously as our ability to calculate numbers and comprehend reading lessons through a single lens of interpretation.
Even a radically different model can end up making its case through familiar academic measures.
I care about reading and math. Of course I do. I also care whether my children have ideas, make friends, try something difficult, and feel comfortable asking for help.
I don’t want my kids to be coddled. I do want them to be noticed.
And I have a responsibility there, too.
Sometimes the invitation to play comes just as I’m about to start the laundry or clean up the mess they’ve made. Sometimes I’m on my phone when they wish I wasn’t.
I can spend an impressive amount of time researching the ideal environment for my children and still miss an invitation to sit on the floor with them.
I don’t get it right every time. I do know they leave our house knowing I love them, respect them, love being their mother, and have their backs.
I want a school that helps us build on that. One where adults know them well enough to recognize both a difficulty and a possibility. Where helping children reach their potential includes understanding what that potential might look like for each child.
I’m still asking questions about school. I’ll keep asking when something doesn’t seem right.
But I’m also thinking about the life around it. Friends coming over. Music in the house. Making things. Being outside. Knowing our neighbors. Having adults beyond their parents who care about them.
Those things deserve a place in the calculation, alongside tuition, class size, and test scores.
When I wrote about ChatGPT in 2023, I hoped technology might give families more freedom to learn and live differently.
I still hope that.
For now, I’m trying to build a childhood with enough challenge to help my children grow, enough attention to recognize when they need help, and enough connection that they know they belong.
And sometimes that starts with putting down my phone and letting the laundry wait.
How do you balance wanting them to thrive with wanting them to just breathe? I want to hear how other moms are navigating this. Write in and share your story. Let’s talk about it.